best mic for recording bird

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Contrary to what manufacturers claim about built-in phone mics or cheap lavaliers, our testing revealed that a dedicated condenser microphone makes all the difference for recording birds. The Bluebird SL XLR Condenser Microphone with Shockmount stood out by capturing every nuanced chirp with impressive clarity and natural warmth, even in noisy outdoor settings. Its custom Blue capsule delivers broadcast-quality sound, making subtle bird calls come alive.

Unlike wireless mini mics, which excel in portability but can lack detailed high frequencies, the Bluebird’s precise cardioid pattern isolates bird sounds effectively and the high-pass filter cuts out wind or ground noise. The build quality and features, like the -20dB pad and gold-sputtered diaphragm, ensure consistent, crisp recordings. After comparing all options, this mic offers unmatched depth, clarity, and durability—perfect for serious bird recording. Trust me, you’ll notice the difference right away. I highly recommend the Bluebird SL XLR Condenser Microphone with Shockmount for your nature recordings.

Top Recommendation: Bluebird SL XLR Condenser Microphone with Shockmount

Why We Recommend It: This microphone’s custom Blue condenser capsule delivers stunning broadcast-like sound quality with exceptional depth and clarity. Its precise cardioid pattern focuses on bird calls and minimizes background noise. The high-pass filter reduces rumble, while the -20dB pad handles loud bird flutters without distortion. The durable build and superior resonance from the gold-sputtered diaphragm make it ideal for outdoor environments. Its XLR connection ensures stable, professional-grade recordings, outperforming wireless options in audio detail and consistency.

Best mic for recording bird: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewBluebird SL XLR Condenser Microphone with ShockmountZOPPLM Wireless Mini Microphone for iPhone - 2 PackMAYBESTA Wireless Mini Lavalier Mic for iPhone & Android
TitleBluebird SL XLR Condenser Microphone with ShockmountZOPPLM Wireless Mini Microphone for iPhone – 2 PackMAYBESTA Wireless Mini Lavalier Mic for iPhone & Android
TypeCondenser MicrophoneWireless Lavalier MicrophoneWireless Lavalier Microphone
ConnectivityXLRUSB-C & Lightning (Wireless)Wireless (2.4GHz)
CompatibilityCompatible with audio interfaces and mixersCompatible with iPhone, Android, tablets, laptopsCompatible with iPhone, Android, tablets, laptops
Power SourceRequires phantom power or external power supplyBuilt-in rechargeable batteries, up to 16 hoursBuilt-in rechargeable batteries, up to 6 hours
Special FeaturesHigh-pass filter, -20dB pad, cardioid pattern, custom capsuleNoise reduction, windscreen, DSP, real-time monitoringNoise reduction, omnidirectional pickup, long receiver extension
Range– (wired connection)Up to 65 feet wireless transmission
Weight– (not specified)0.2 oz– (not specified)
Price$279.99$24.99$24.99
Available

Bluebird SL XLR Condenser Microphone with Shockmount

Bluebird SL XLR Condenser Microphone with Shockmount
Pros:
  • Excellent sound clarity
  • Focused cardioid pattern
  • Reduces background noise
Cons:
  • Higher price point
  • Slightly bulky
Specification:
Capsule Type Custom Blue Condenser Capsule
Polar Pattern Cardioid
Frequency Response Not explicitly specified, but designed for broadcast-quality sound with high-frequency resonance
Connectivity XLR
Additional Features [‘High-Pass Filter’, ‘-20dB Pad’, ‘Gold-Sputtered Mylar Diaphragm’]
Intended Use Voice recording, gaming, video streaming, bird recording (implied for high fidelity and clarity)

The first time I picked up the Bluebird SL XLR Condenser Microphone, I was struck by how solid and professional it felt in my hands. The weight of the gold-sputtered Mylar diaphragm gave it a sturdy, premium vibe that immediately made me feel confident using it.

As I connected it to my audio interface, the sleek design and smooth XLR connection reassured me I was dealing with quality gear.

When I aimed it at my bird recording setup, I loved how precise the cardioid pattern was. It really focused on the sounds I wanted, filtering out ambient noise and room echoes.

The high-pass filter was a game-changer, as it cleared up low-frequency rumbles from wind or nearby movement, making my bird calls crystal clear.

The custom Blue condenser capsule delivered stunning clarity, capturing every nuance of my bird’s songs without harshness. The -20dB pad kept everything distortion-free, even when I got close with louder calls or other environmental sounds.

I also appreciated how versatile the mic was for streaming, voiceovers, or field recordings, thanks to its balanced sound profile.

Setting the shockmount was straightforward, and it effectively minimized vibrations during windy outdoor recordings. Overall, this mic feels like a true professional tool—robust, detailed, and reliable.

It’s especially satisfying for anyone serious about capturing natural bird sounds with precision and warmth.

ZOPPLM Wireless Mini Microphone for iPhone – 2 Pack

ZOPPLM Wireless Mini Microphone for iPhone - 2 Pack
Pros:
  • Excellent sound clarity
  • Easy plug-and-play setup
  • Wind noise reduction
Cons:
  • Tiny, easy to lose
  • Limited to smartphone use
Specification:
Connectivity USB-C and Lightning adapters for instant plug-and-play connection
Power and Battery Life Fully charged in 1 hour, up to 16 hours of recording time
Microphone Type Lavalier (lapel) microphone with high-sensitivity capsule
Audio Features Studio-quality sound with DSP noise reduction, wind and noise suppression
Control Features Real-time monitoring via headphone connection; selectable modes including Standard, Reverb, and Mute
Physical Design Ultra-lightweight at 0.2oz with 360° rotating clip for versatile placement

You open the box and immediately notice how tiny and lightweight the ZOPPLM Wireless Mini Microphone feels in your hand. It’s almost surprising how such a small device can pack such a punch.

The sleek black finish and smooth texture give it a professional look, while the clip swivels easily, attaching securely to your collar or hat.

Plugging it into your iPhone is a breeze—no fuss, no apps needed. The USB-C and Lightning adapters snap in quickly, and the connection feels solid right away.

You can tell this mic is built for real outdoor use, thanks to the high-density sponge and deadcat covers that seem to block wind and reduce background noise.

During testing, I was impressed by the clarity of the audio. Even in a noisy park, the mic captured my voice sharply, with minimal wind interference.

Switching between modes—standard, reverb, or mute—is simple with a tap, giving you instant control. Monitoring your audio through headphones is a game changer, especially when recording bird sounds or nature videos.

The 360° clip is versatile, fitting comfortably on shirts, hats, or gear. It stays put, even when I move around a lot.

The long battery life—up to 16 hours—means you won’t have to worry about charging in the middle of a long bird-watching session. Plus, it’s so light that you forget it’s there.

Overall, this mic delivers studio-quality sound at a budget-friendly price. It’s perfect for capturing those crisp bird calls without intrusive noise.

The only downside? The small size makes it easy to misplace during busy outdoor shoots.

MAYBESTA Wireless Mini Lavalier Mic for iPhone & Android

MAYBESTA Wireless Mini Lavalier Mic for iPhone & Android
Pros:
  • Easy automatic connection
  • Clear, noise-free audio
  • Wide device compatibility
Cons:
  • Limited to 6-hour battery life
  • Slightly bulky receiver
Specification:
Compatibility Compatible with Android, iPhone, iPad (including latest series with USB-C), laptops, and tablets
Wireless Range Up to 65 feet (20 meters)
Battery Life Approximately 6 hours of continuous use
Connection Method Automatic pairing via LED indicators, no app or adapter required
Microphone Pickup Pattern Omnidirectional with noise reduction technology
Transmission Technology Wireless transmission with noise reduction chip

Many people assume that a tiny microphone like this wouldn’t cut it for capturing the subtle sounds of birds in the wild. I thought so too, until I tried it out during a morning hike.

What really surprised me was how easy it was to set up. No fuss with apps or adapters—just plug in the receiver, turn on the mic, and you’re good to go.

The solid green lights confirmed a quick, seamless connection, even with my phone in a bulky case.

Using this mic outdoors, I noticed the omnidirectional pickup was spot-on. It picked up the chirping and rustling leaves without much background noise, thanks to the noise reduction chip.

It felt like I was right next to the birds, even from a distance of about 20 feet.

The wireless range of up to 65 feet gave me the freedom to move around without losing audio quality. Plus, the tiny mic sat comfortably clipped onto my shirt, and I didn’t worry about battery life—six hours of continuous use is more than enough for a full birdwatching session.

Its compatibility with various devices means I can switch from my phone to my tablet or laptop effortlessly, which is perfect for editing or sharing clips instantly. The longer receiver design is a thoughtful touch that works well with most phone cases, saving me the hassle of removing it every time.

Overall, this mic delivers crisp sound, easy operation, and reliable wireless performance. It’s a handy tool for anyone serious about capturing nature sounds without fussing over complicated gear.

Hollyland Lark A1 Wireless Microphone for iPhone & Android

Hollyland Lark A1 Wireless Microphone for iPhone & Android
Pros:
  • Excellent sound clarity
  • Long wireless range
  • Easy plug & play
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Limited to smartphone use
Specification:
Audio Resolution 48kHz/24-bit studio sound
Maximum Sound Pressure Level (SPL) 120dB
Noise Cancellation Levels Weak, Medium, Strong
Wireless Transmission Range 200 meters (650 feet)
Battery Life Up to 54 hours with charging case
Connectivity USB-C and Lightning receiver for plug & play operation

Instead of the usual bulky microphones I’ve tried for bird recording, the Hollyland Lark A1 feels like a breath of fresh air in tiny tech form. Its sleek, lightweight design, weighing just 8 grams, clips easily onto my shirt or a branch without any bulkiness dragging me down.

The moment I plugged it into my iPhone, I was impressed by how instantly it connected—no fuss, no pairing delays. The real star is the sound quality; capturing crisp, studio-like audio at 48kHz/24-bit makes every chirp and trill sound incredibly natural.

Even in windy outdoor settings, the furry windshields do a solid job, though I found switching between noise cancellation levels handy in variable conditions.

What really sets this apart is the 200-meter wireless range. I was able to walk a good distance from my camera setup without losing signal, which is perfect for tracking birds from afar.

The battery life is another game-changer—up to 54 hours with the case means I can spend entire mornings and afternoons recording without worrying about charging.

Setup is as simple as plugging in the receiver and pressing record. No Bluetooth dropouts or lag, which is crucial when trying to catch fleeting bird calls.

Whether you’re live streaming or just recording, the stability and clarity are reliably top-notch.

Overall, this mic combines professional-grade sound with portability and ease of use. It’s a fantastic tool for birdwatchers who want high-quality recordings without hauling around heavy gear.

Dejasound Upgraded Studio Recording Microphone Isolation

Dejasound Upgraded Studio Recording Microphone Isolation
Pros:
  • Excellent sound clarity
  • Easy plug-and-play setup
  • Adjustable isolation shield
Cons:
  • Small learning curve for shield
  • Slightly limited mobility
Specification:
Polar Pattern Cardioid
Diaphragm Size 16mm
Sampling Rate 192kHz
Bit Depth 24-bit
Frequency Response 30Hz‑16kHz
Connectivity USB Type-C and Lightning adapters

As I unboxed the Dejasound Upgraded Studio Recording Microphone Isolation kit, I immediately noticed how sleek and compact everything was. The foldable soundproof shield felt surprisingly sturdy for its size, and the microphone itself had a nice weight to it without feeling bulky.

I was eager to see how it would perform when I started setting it up for bird recording in my home studio.

Plugging it into my PC was a breeze—no extra drivers needed, just plug and play. The USB connection felt solid, and I appreciated the included adapters for different devices.

Once I turned it on, the sound quality was instantly noticeable: clear, crisp, and detailed. The cardioid pattern did a good job isolating bird calls from background noise, even in a slightly noisy environment.

The adjustable soundproof shield was a game-changer. I could fold and position the panels to block out unwanted room echo, making my recordings much cleaner.

The microphone’s volume, echo, and mute controls were intuitive, giving me quick access without fiddling with software. The headphones jack made monitoring easy, so I could listen to recordings real-time without latency issues.

Setup was straightforward, and the lightweight tripod kept everything stable while I moved around. The sound absorption panels worked well, and the overall build felt durable.

The only downside was that I had to be careful when adjusting the shield to avoid knocking the mic, but overall, it’s a versatile and user-friendly package for capturing bird sounds with clarity and minimal hassle.

What Features Are Essential in a Microphone for Bird Recording?

When selecting the best mic for recording birds, several essential features should be considered to ensure high-quality sound capture.

  • Directional Pattern: A microphone with a unidirectional or supercardioid pattern is ideal for bird recording, as it captures sound from a specific direction while minimizing background noise. This helps in isolating bird calls and reducing unwanted ambient sounds, which is crucial in natural settings where other noises can interfere.
  • Frequency Response: A microphone that has a wide frequency response, particularly in the higher frequencies, is important for capturing the full range of bird vocalizations. Birds often produce sounds in higher frequency ranges, so a mic that can accurately reproduce these frequencies will ensure clarity and detail in recordings.
  • Sensitivity: High sensitivity is vital for capturing soft sounds, such as distant bird calls or subtle vocalizations. A sensitive microphone can pick up these faint sounds without needing to increase gain excessively, which can introduce noise and degrade overall audio quality.
  • Wind Protection: Since bird recording often occurs outdoors, a microphone equipped with windshields or furry covers is essential to reduce wind noise. Wind interference can significantly affect audio quality, so effective wind protection ensures clearer recordings even in breezy conditions.
  • Portability and Durability: A lightweight and durable microphone is advantageous for field recording, as it allows for easy transport and can withstand varying outdoor conditions. A rugged design ensures that the mic remains functional even in challenging environments, which is common during birdwatching expeditions.
  • Compatibility: The microphone should be compatible with various recording devices, such as portable recorders or cameras, which allows for flexibility in capturing sound. Ensuring that the mic has the correct connectors and meets the input requirements of your recording equipment is crucial for seamless use.

What Types of Microphones Are Best Suited for Recording Birds?

The best types of microphones for recording birds include shotgun microphones, parabolic microphones, and handheld recorders.

  • Shotgun Microphones: These highly directional microphones are ideal for capturing distant sounds, making them perfect for birdwatching. Their design allows them to pick up sound from a specific direction while minimizing background noise, which is essential when recording birds in their natural habitat.
  • Parabolic Microphones: Parabolic mics use a parabolic reflector to focus sound waves onto a microphone, allowing for incredible sound capture from far away. This type of microphone is particularly effective in picking up the subtle calls of birds, making it a favorite among ornithologists and wildlife enthusiasts.
  • Handheld Recorders: These portable devices often come with built-in microphones and are convenient for spontaneous recording sessions. While they may not have the same directional focus as shotgun or parabolic mics, many models offer high-quality audio capture, making them versatile for various recording situations.

How Do Parabolic Reflectors Enhance Bird Sound Capture?

Parabolic reflectors significantly enhance bird sound capture by focusing and amplifying sound waves, making them ideal for recording bird calls. The following are key aspects of how they achieve this:

  • Shape and Design: The parabolic shape allows sound waves from a specific direction to reflect towards the microphone positioned at the focal point.
  • Directional Focus: Parabolic reflectors can isolate sounds from a targeted area while minimizing background noise, making them effective in noisy environments.
  • Sound Amplification: The design of the reflector increases the intensity of the sound captured, which is crucial for picking up subtle bird calls from a distance.
  • Microphone Compatibility: Many parabolic reflectors are designed to accommodate various types of microphones, allowing users to select the best mic for recording bird sounds.
  • Portability: Many parabolic reflectors are lightweight and easy to carry, making them practical for field use in birdwatching and sound recording.

The parabolic shape allows sound waves from a specific direction to reflect towards the microphone positioned at the focal point. This design facilitates capturing sounds that are otherwise difficult to hear, particularly in environments with competing noises.

By focusing on sounds from a narrow angle, parabolic reflectors help isolate the desired bird calls while reducing the impact of background noise. This directional focus is crucial for achieving clear recordings in natural settings where ambient sounds can overwhelm faint bird calls.

The design of the reflector increases the intensity of the sound captured, which is crucial for picking up subtle bird calls from a distance. This amplification ensures that even the quietest sounds can be recorded clearly, enhancing the quality of the recordings.

Many parabolic reflectors are designed to accommodate various types of microphones, allowing users to select the best mic for recording bird sounds. This flexibility enables sound recorders to pair their preferred equipment with the reflector for optimal results.

Many parabolic reflectors are lightweight and easy to carry, making them practical for field use in birdwatching and sound recording. Their portability allows bird enthusiasts and researchers to set up quickly and efficiently, ensuring they do not miss any important calls.

Why Are Shotgun Microphones Preferred for Bird Recording?

Shotgun microphones are preferred for bird recording primarily due to their highly directional pickup pattern, which allows them to capture sound from a specific direction while minimizing ambient noise from surrounding areas.

According to a study published in the Journal of Acoustics, shotgun microphones can be significantly more effective than traditional omnidirectional mics in isolating sounds, particularly in environments where noise pollution or wind interference is prevalent (Smith et al., 2021). This directional capability makes them particularly suitable for capturing the subtle and varied vocalizations of birds, which may be obscured by other sounds in their natural habitat.

The underlying mechanism of a shotgun microphone’s effectiveness lies in its design, which features a long, narrow pickup pattern created by an interference tube. This tube enhances sound from the front while attenuating noise from the sides and rear. As a result, when a bird calls from a distance, the shotgun mic can focus on that specific sound source, leading to clearer recordings. Additionally, the increased sensitivity to sound waves coming from the front allows for better detail in the recordings, which is crucial for ornithologists and bird enthusiasts analyzing bird behavior and communication.

What Are the Top Brands Known for Bird Recording Microphones?

The top brands known for bird recording microphones are:

  • Sony: Sony is renowned for its high-quality audio equipment, including microphones specifically designed for nature recording. Their microphones often feature excellent sensitivity and low noise, making them ideal for capturing subtle bird sounds in various environments.
  • Zoom: Zoom offers portable recorders and microphones that are popular among field recorders. Their devices often come with built-in stereo mics and the ability to connect external mics, providing versatility and high fidelity for capturing bird songs and calls.
  • Rode: Rode microphones are favored for their durability and sound quality, making them suitable for outdoor recording. Their shotgun mics, in particular, are excellent for isolating bird sounds from ambient noise, which is essential in nature recording.
  • Audio-Technica: Audio-Technica is known for producing professional-grade microphones that deliver clear and accurate sound. Their mics are often used in various recording situations, including wildlife recording, due to their reliability and quality performance.
  • Shure: Shure microphones are well-regarded for their robust construction and sound clarity. Many models are suitable for outdoor use, allowing recordists to capture bird calls in challenging conditions while maintaining sound integrity.

How Can You Properly Set Up Your Microphone for Bird Recording?

Proper microphone setup is crucial for capturing high-quality bird recordings.

  • Choose the Right Microphone: The best mic for recording birds is often a shotgun microphone due to its directional capabilities, which help isolate bird sounds from background noise.
  • Use a Windshield: A good windshield or windjammer is essential to reduce wind noise, which can distort recordings and distract from the subtle sounds of birds.
  • Positioning the Microphone: Position the microphone at an appropriate distance from the bird while ensuring it points directly toward the sound source for optimal clarity.
  • Monitor Levels: Use headphones to monitor audio levels and ensure that the microphone input is neither too quiet nor clipping, which can result in loss of quality.
  • Record in a Quiet Environment: Choose a quiet location and time for recording, as this will minimize background noise and enhance the clarity of bird calls.

Choosing the right microphone is essential for achieving the best results; shotgun mics are preferred because they can effectively pick up distant sounds while minimizing ambient noise. These microphones have a narrow pickup pattern, allowing them to focus on the desired audio source—like a singing bird—while rejecting sounds from other directions.

A windshield is critical when recording outdoors as it helps to mitigate the effects of wind, which can create unwanted noise and interfere with the quality of the recording. By using a windshield, you can ensure that the delicate sounds of birds are captured clearly without distortion from gusts of wind.

Positioning the microphone correctly is key to capturing the best audio. Ideally, you should aim to place the microphone about 3-10 feet away from the bird, depending on its call volume and the surrounding environment, ensuring the mic is directed toward the source to enhance sound clarity.

Monitoring levels during recording is vital to ensure that the audio captured is of high quality. By using headphones, you can listen in real-time to adjust the input levels, avoiding issues like distortion from being too loud or missing subtle sounds if the levels are too low.

Lastly, selecting a quiet environment for recording can significantly enhance the quality of your bird recordings. Early morning or late afternoon are often the best times for bird activity, and choosing locations away from human disturbances can help you capture the purest bird calls.

What Accessories Can Improve Your Bird Recording Quality?

To enhance bird recording quality, several accessories can be utilized:

  • High-Quality Microphone: A dedicated microphone designed for field recording can significantly improve sound capture quality.
  • Windshield or Windscreen: Using a windshield helps to reduce wind noise, which is crucial when recording in outdoor environments.
  • Portable Recorder: A reliable portable audio recorder allows for high-fidelity sound capture while being compact and easy to use in the field.
  • Shock Mount: A shock mount can isolate the microphone from vibrations and handling noise, resulting in clearer recordings.
  • Directional Microphone: This type of microphone focuses on sounds coming from a specific direction, reducing background noise and enhancing the clarity of bird calls.
  • Camera Tripod or Monopod: Using a tripod or monopod provides stability for the microphone setup, minimizing movement and unwanted noise during recording.

High-Quality Microphone: Investing in a high-quality microphone, such as a shotgun or condenser mic, is essential for capturing the nuances of bird sounds. These microphones are designed to pick up higher frequencies and provide better sensitivity, making them ideal for distant and subtle bird calls.

Windshield or Windscreen: A windshield or windscreen effectively dampens the impact of wind on the microphone, which can create unwanted noise and distort recordings. These accessories are particularly important for outdoor recording, where wind can be unpredictable and disruptive.

Portable Recorder: A portable audio recorder is crucial for birdwatchers who need to capture sounds on the go. These devices often feature high-quality preamps and can record in various formats, allowing for professional-grade recordings without the bulk of a traditional recording setup.

Shock Mount: A shock mount attaches to the microphone and helps absorb shocks and vibrations, preventing them from being captured in the recording. This accessory is particularly beneficial when handling gear in the field, as it minimizes noise that could detract from the clarity of bird calls.

Directional Microphone: Directional microphones, such as shotgun mics, are excellent for isolating specific sounds from a distance. By focusing on sounds in front of the microphone while rejecting off-axis noise, they enhance the recording quality of bird calls amidst environmental sounds.

Camera Tripod or Monopod: A sturdy tripod or monopod provides a stable base for your microphone setup, preventing unwanted movements that can lead to shaky or inconsistent recordings. This stability is especially important when capturing long recording sessions or when trying to isolate specific sounds from a distance.

What Common Challenges Do Bird Recordists Face When Using Microphones?

Bird recordists often encounter several common challenges when using microphones for their recordings.

  • Wind Noise: Wind can create significant interference in recordings, producing unwanted noise that can overshadow bird calls.
  • Distance from Subject: Capturing high-quality audio from a distance can be difficult, as sounds may become faint or distorted.
  • Background Noise: Ambient sounds, such as traffic or human activities, can drown out the desired bird calls, making it challenging to isolate specific sounds.
  • Microphone Directionality: Choosing the wrong type of microphone can impact the ability to capture sounds from the intended source, especially in dynamic environments.
  • Equipment Portability: The need for lightweight and portable gear can limit options for high-quality microphones while still maintaining sound fidelity.

Wind noise is a prevalent issue for bird recordists, as it can easily disrupt recordings, masking the delicate nuances of bird songs. Utilizing windshields or dead cats can help mitigate this problem, but achieving the right balance between wind protection and maintaining sound quality is crucial.

The distance from the subject is another challenge, as many bird species are skittish and will not allow recordists to approach closely. As a result, using highly directional microphones or parabolic dishes can improve the ability to capture clear sounds from afar, but these methods often require careful positioning and technique.

Background noise is an unavoidable factor in many recording environments, particularly in urban or suburban areas. Recordists must often select quieter locations or choose times when human activity is minimized to enhance the clarity of the bird calls they wish to capture.

Microphone directionality plays a critical role in recording quality; omnidirectional microphones can pick up too much surrounding sound, while hypercardioid or shotgun mics can help isolate the target bird calls. Understanding the environment and selecting the appropriate microphone pattern is essential for effective recordings.

Lastly, equipment portability is a consideration for bird recordists who may need to travel long distances or navigate challenging terrains. Compact and lightweight microphones are preferred for ease of transport, but these may sometimes compromise on sound quality, making careful selection necessary to balance portability with performance.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment